A bed. A window. A washroom. That’s all there in a hotel room. Three simple things, and yet so much more. New York City is a town of great hotel rooms, so we set out to identify the very best of the best. Not the most opulent suites, but, rather, those standard rooms that exceed themselves. We started with a list of about 50, which we managed to narrow down to about 30, and then visited each and every one. We saw more than 100 rooms all over the city—from Central Park West to the Bowery and back. We jumped on beds, tested showers, crawled around looking for electrical outlets, opened and closed blinds, found ourselves standing in darkened rooms with strange men in order to test the blackout shades, tried on robes and gazed wistfully out windows. But what stood out most was the philosophy of hospitality that each hotel exhibited. It was the incomparable Amy Vanderbilt who said, “Good manners have much to do with the emotions. To make them ring true, one must feel them, not merely exhibit them.” Ultimately, it is the sincerity and graciousness of a hotel’s staff that make the rooms feel like home—or something better.
From Our Archive
This story was published before Summer 2021, when we launched our new digital experience.
The Perfect New York Hotel Rooms
Most Read In Travel
A Beloved Landmark Gets a New Life
The Columns Hotel in New Orleans keeps its old soul in a spectacular unveiling.
The Other Side of Paradise
A traveling writer explores the historic allure and complicated cultural perception of French Polynesia.
A first-time traveler to Africa examines the complicated relationship between safari tourism and conservation.
A Sustainable Future
Three luxury properties provide insight and inspiration for environmentally conscious travelers.
A Cinematic Stay at Blancaneaux Lodge and Turtle Inn
Visionary director Francis Ford Coppola’s Belizean mountain retreat and seaside escape.
The Great Spa Towns of Europe
Take a dip into UNESCO’s recently designated therapeutic springs.
Most Read Stories
The Perfect Cup
Terra Kaffe’s espresso machine elevates your morning ritual with the press of a button.