It would be hard to overstate the significance of the original Ryland Inn, which had its run from 1991 to 2007. Patrons flocked to central New Jersey from Manhattan and Philadelphia; the 2000 New York Times review, titled “Reaching for Perfection,” opened with the line “Words fail me.” Chef Craig Shelton was the first to win a Best Chef: Mid-Atlantic James Beard award for the Garden State, thanks, in part, to the on-site garden he was cooking from two decades before farm-to-table became a cliché. Then, in 2007, a pipe burst in the middle of service. Debts mounted, permits expired; the place never got back on its feet. Five years and $2 million later, the Ryland Inn, an hour west of Manhattan, is back in every sense. Shelton handpicked his successor—a young chef named Anthony Bucco who had been moving from place to place and making fascinating food that was ready for a larger stage. Bucco raids the resurrected garden for the sliced peaches on a flawless fluke crudo, the muddled harvest cherries in a sake-and-Champagne cocktail and the fresh herbs and edible flowers woven into his signature intermezzo salad. A posh, polished and encyclopedically stocked bar occupies the space between the dramatic entrance and two serene dining rooms. It’s the kind of place where you can stop in for a Harvest margarita—which employs a shot of beet juice as an earthy, unexpected foil to the citrus and silver tequila—even if you don’t feel like a seven-course tasting. But the tasting is the thing. Forget the menu, forgo the wine list; let the Ryland call the shots and words will likely fail you, too. At 115 Old Hwy. 28, Whitehouse Station; 908-534-4011; rylandinnnj.com.
From Our Archive
This story was published before Summer 2021, when we launched our new digital experience.
Revisiting the Ryland Inn
Most Read In Travel
A Beloved Landmark Gets a New Life
The Columns Hotel in New Orleans keeps its old soul in a spectacular unveiling.
The Other Side of Paradise
A traveling writer explores the historic allure and complicated cultural perception of French Polynesia.
A first-time traveler to Africa examines the complicated relationship between safari tourism and conservation.
A Sustainable Future
Three luxury properties provide insight and inspiration for environmentally conscious travelers.
A Cinematic Stay at Blancaneaux Lodge and Turtle Inn
Visionary director Francis Ford Coppola’s Belizean mountain retreat and seaside escape.
The Great Spa Towns of Europe
Take a dip into UNESCO’s recently designated therapeutic springs.
Most Read Stories
The Deep Dive
A light conversation with David Lynch on Transcendental Meditation, the unified field, and what happens after we die.