From Our Archive
This story was published before Summer 2021, when we launched our new digital experience.

Go Fish

Glowingly fresh traditional sushi

MOST READ TRAVEL
Our Favorite Shop-Small Destinations of the Year

Editors’ Picks

Our Favorite Shop-Small Destinations of the Year

Our editors’ picks for special finds at unique stores.

In a Pickle

Outdoors

In a Pickle

Why pickleball is the feel-good game craze we all need right now.

Benevolent Spirits

Wine and Spirits

Benevolent Spirits

A selection of alcohol-free mixers and aperitifs for a healthy, holistic cocktail...

At the bright, pleasantly trim Sushi Man—located, surprisingly, in a small shopping mall in New York's Westchester County—chef-owner Hideo Aoto crafts impeccable, glowingly fresh traditional sushi, including Osaka's famed battera zushi: marinated mackerel or grilled eel pressed in layers onto rice. For those with a taste for novelty, he creates such succulent innovations as fried-oyster sushi, or grilled eel and spicy tuna atop seaweed-wrapped rice, though he wisely frowns on travesties like inside-out California rolls. Among nonsushi selections: the ethereal usuzukuri, gossamer slices of fluke to dip in the citrus-soy sauce ponzu. Most extraordinary is the bara chirashi, or "loosely scattered" sushi: With lightning speed, Aoto minces confetti-like filaments and flecks of grilled eel, smoked salmon, crabmeat, egg custard, shiitake mushrooms, cucumber, daikon sprouts, and mint leaf. Next he scatters these over the rice, along with thin pieces of tuna, squid, and shrimp, then tops it all off with salmon roe, sesame seeds, seaweed, and sweet eel sauce. The result is a lesson on the interaction of texture and flavor as all ingredients are tasted at once.

The flavors deepen if the covered box stays overnight in the refrigerator, as I discovered after taking a portion home. Some of Aoto's best creations are those that he prepares impromptu for steady customers whose taste he knows. Dinner, $100. At 724 Saw Mill River Rd., Ardsley, New York; 914-693-8800; fax 914-674-1019.

Restaurant prices reflect a three-course dinner for two, excluding beverages and gratuity.

Newsletter

Let’s Keep in Touch

Subscribe to our newsletter

You’re no longer on our newsletter list, but you can resubscribe anytime.