From Our Archive
This story was published before Summer 2021, when we launched our new digital experience.

A New Monticello (in Connecticut)

In the 1700s, it took Thomas Jefferson nearly 40 years to build Monticello, his iconic neo-Palladian plantation; 250 years later, it took S. Prestley Blake just 14 months to build his. Blake, a co-founder of the ice cream chain Friendly’s, has long traded in Americana; for his 100th birthday, he wanted to leave his hometown of Somers, Connecticut, with a parting gift that guaranteed both its legacy and his own: a near-perfect replica of what he calls “the most prominent private home in America.” Jefferson had time on his side; Blake had capitalism. “I told Bill LaPlante, the builder, if he finished the house before I died,” Blake says, “I’d give him a $50,000 bonus.”

That incentive got Blake a 10,000-square-foot 18th-century mansion built to 21st-century standards. From the outside, it could be on the nickel: that Doric-columned portico, the octagonal dome. But the balustrades are forest-friendly polyurethane, the roof is a weather-resistant slate composite, and the home’s energy is geothermal. Where Jefferson built cramped bedrooms, outdoor privies, and passageways to Sally Hemings, Monticello 2.0 has a light-filled open floor plan and a double-height foyer. Eleven artisans spent six months finessing 14 rooms’ worth of crown molding, coffered ceilings, and mahogany-and-oak floors. “Jefferson was forever refining Monticello with an eye to convenience,” says Blake’s wife, Helen. “That gave us license to make changes; this home is the modern continuation of his work.”

“Yeah,” adds Blake. “And it has a three-car garage.”

At 732 Hall Hill Road, Somers, Connecticut; $6.5 million;

Image Credit: © Daniel Wodecki


Let’s Keep in Touch

Subscribe to our newsletter

Come On In

U.S. issued American Express Platinum Card® and Centurion® Members, enter the first six digits of your card number to access your complimentary subscription.

Learn about membership.